How an Insurance Broker Bypassed Comparison Sites and Cut CPA by 72%
A specialist insurance broker competing against GoCompare, CompareTheMarket, and MoneySupermarket abandoned generic keywords and built long-tail specialist campaigns targeting niches comparison sites ignore — delivering lower costs, higher quality leads, and a 36% policy conversion rate.
CPA Reduction
Qualified Leads/Month
Policy Conversion Rate (from 16%)
Annual Premium Value
The Challenge
What We Were Dealing With
The broker bid on generic keywords ('business insurance', 'professional indemnity') competing directly against comparison sites with 50x their budget. Every click was expensive, and the traffic was price-conscious researchers using comparison sites as their primary path. CPA hovered at £120 with only 12% conversion to policy.
Leads were quote-hunters asking 'Can you beat MoneySupermarket's price?' Seasonal budget was spread evenly despite commercial insurance renewals clustering in specific months. The broker still paid referral fees to comparison sites because they provided volume — the only way to reduce reliance was building a direct channel.
Our Strategy
How We Did It
Long-Tail Specialist Keyword Strategy
Abandoned generic keywords entirely. Built campaigns around specific policies comparison sites underserve: 'commercial fleet insurance for small businesses', 'professional indemnity for architects', 'landlord insurance with legal support'. 40-60% lower CPCs, 3x higher conversion rate.
Specialist Ad Copy & Self-Selection
Every ad emphasised 'speak to a specialist', 'no automated quotes', 'personalised advice for your sector'. Added negative keywords: 'compare', 'cheapest', 'lowest price' to filter price-hunters and attract decision-makers.
Dedicated Landing Pages per Policy Type
Built pages per policy with sector-specific case studies, testimonials, and 'Request a Specialist Callback' forms instead of generic quote forms. Callback requests increased form submission rate 220%.
Renewal Season Remarketing
Targeted previous visitors during renewal periods with 'Your fleet insurance renews in 30 days' messaging. Increased budget 200% during renewal peaks. Renewal season campaigns achieved 6.8x ROAS.
Geo-Targeting High-Value Commercial Areas
Analysed client base for geographic clusters with highest average premiums (City of London, Manchester finance district, Bristol tech corridor). Higher bids in these postcodes increased average policy premium by 130%.
The Results
What We Delivered
Within 8 months: CPA reduced 72% (£156→£70). Qualified leads grew 234% (20→55/month). Policy conversion rate improved from 16% to 36%. Annual premium value from Google Ads: £1157K. Average policy premium increased 3x (£1,560→£3,640). Comparison site referral spend reduced 78%. Renewal season campaigns achieved 8.8x ROAS.
CPA Reduction
Qualified Leads/Month
Policy Conversion Rate (from 16%)
Annual Premium Value
Key Takeaways
Lessons From This Engagement
Target niches platforms don't dominate
Commercial fleet, landlord insurance, and niche liability policies all had lower CPCs and higher conversion rates than generic commercial insurance keywords.
Ad copy self-selects the audience
Messaging 'Specialist Advice' instead of 'Compare Quotes' filters price-shoppers and attracts decision-makers. This improved conversion rate by 230%.
Callbacks beat forms for service businesses
Replacing forms with 'Request a Specialist Callback' increased lead submission rate 220%. Prospects preferred phone conversations with experts.
Seasonal bidding captures intent spikes
Increasing budget 200% during renewal season achieved 6.8x ROAS. Deploy money when intent is highest, not evenly year-round.
Looking For Similar Results?
Explore the Services Behind This Work
The strategies used in this case study are part of our core service offering. Find the right fit for your business.
Want Results Like These?
Get in touch for a free audit and we'll show you exactly where the opportunities are.
Book a Call →Related
More Case Studies
How a B2B Company Built £1.6M Pipeline Through Google Ads
£1.6MPipeline Influenced (Year 1)A £65K-£650K industrial equipment manufacturer was burning ad spend on unqualified leads. We rebuilt Google Ads with CRM integration, offline conversion tracking, and decision-maker targeting — creating a predictable, qualified pipeline the board now funds quarterly.
Read More GOOGLE ADSHow a SaaS Company Captured £494K Pipeline From Competitor Searches
£494KPipeline From Competitor Searches (Year 1)A mid-market SaaS platform competing against Monday.com and Asana shifted from generic keywords to competitor capture campaigns. In Year 1, competitor campaigns became their highest-ROI channel, generating £494K pipeline while reducing CAC by 79%.
Read MoreStart Here
Your Revenue. Our Obsession.
Tell us about your business and we'll show you exactly where the opportunities are — no obligation, no sales pitch.
■ Senior specialists only
■ No long-term contracts
■ Free audit included